Extra Credit

Question: What is the problem with romanticizing nostalgic memories of the past?

F. Scott Fitzgerald, in his book The Great Gatsby, uses Jay Gatsby as an example of how constantly fantasizing about the past creates only disappointing, hollow results. For instance, when Gatsby is finally able to meet Daisy, his longtime love, after so many years she "tumbled short of his dreams," (Fitzgerald 101). Daisy was the reason for every single one of his actions over the previous five years, but even she did not live up to Gatsby's expectations. By romanticizing the few memories Gatsby had of her, he drew so far away from reality that there would be no way any human being could be the Daisy he wants. He was left with a present world, which was disappointing compared to what he imagined. Additionally, it would be impossible for Daisy to remain the same person she was in the past. Gatsby wants Daisy to admit that she only loved him, no one else, but Daisy is not able to. She says "I can't say I never loved Tom," (Fitzgerald 140), which upsets Gatsby greatly. He is unable to process that she loved both of them, and that she is no longer the same woman she was five years ago. It is impossible to recreate the Daisy of the past because she has been shaped by all the new, different experiences she has had during her years without Gatsby. Romanticizing old memories did not help Gatsby in any way - he just became an empty man searching for something that does not exist.